Why Indie Games Aren't Smaller AAA Productions

 This topic has been on my mind for months, but I was never motivated enough to fully explain why indie game development is vastly different from smaller AAA (or AA) productions. While, on the surface, it may seem like indie developers can borrow techniques from AA-AAA studios, the reality is entirely different. Having worked in both AAA and indie teams, I can confidently say that the only true similarity is that both create video games.


But first, let me clarify what I mean by "indie game development." I'm referring to small teams, often fewer than five people, or solo developers, who work with little to no budget—unlike AA or AAA productions, where budgets can reach several millions. AA games, are indeed smaller versions of AAA productions, sharing many of the same workflows and resources.

Now, let’s focus on why indie developers can’t simply borrow strategies from AA or AAA studios.

The Small Business Analogy

To put it simply, being an indie developer is like running a small local fast-food joint, while AAA development is like running a McDonald’s franchise. The business models are completely different. The majority of marketing advice and development strategies are based on what works for AA or AAA studios, but for indie devs, these methods can lead to unnecessary complications.

Quick Iterations vs. Long Development Cycles

When a AAA studio begins development, they conduct extensive market research to define their target audience and ensure a profitable outcome. This approach works well for studios with multi-year development cycles and large budgets to sustain them over time. However, as an indie developer, you don’t have the luxury of waiting four to six years to release a game. Like that small fast-food joint, you need to rely on instinct, quick iterations, and rapid market evaluation.

Indie developers must be agile, adapting to trends or niche opportunities that could gain traction quickly. This means that having shorter development cycles—anywhere from six to 12 months—can be more sustainable. If a game flops, the losses are minimized, and you can move on to your next project quickly. On the flip side, long development cycles increase the risk, such as team members leaving for more lucrative projects, and you can’t blame them. Everyone has to make a living.

Diversifying Income Streams

For indie developers, it’s also essential to diversify income sources. Aside from game sales, you can consider offering game development services, selling courses, or earning from sponsorships and content creation (like YouTube). This is a smart strategy, especially when you need to iterate quickly to survive in the highly competitive world of game development.

In conclusion, while AAA and AA strategies may look appealing, they are often impractical for indie developers. Shorter cycles, quick iterations, and a diversified approach are key to surviving in the indie space in most cases.


 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Painful Cuts I Had to Make to My Game

Image
 As much as we hate them, cuts in game development are often necessary. If I’m being honest, I’ve never worked on a project where we didn’t have to make some tough decisions. You start with bigger aspirations—dozens of sprites, backgrounds, and CGs—only to realize that everything takes an insane amount of time and resources. Parallel Pulse was no different. The original vision for the game was something akin to TWEWY in terms of combat, but with a narrative more aligned with the Persona series, where you bond and hang out with friends. The game started as an action RPG, and until mid-May, I was set on this approach. But then reality hit—with each sprite taking way more than what I had initially thought it'd take. In a previous devlog, I gave you a glimpse of how much effort goes into creating a single sprite sheet. It goes without saying that this became a nightmare for me—and not just for the main character but for each enemy as well. Every enemy needed at least three animations, ...
Read more

Should you juggle between multiple game dev projects?

Image
I think the majority of indie devs juggle multiple projects, and for good reason. I want to talk about whether this approach is beneficial or not. You often hear people saying you should focus on one thing at a time, but I believe that what's right for one person isn't necessarily right for another. Humans are naturally inclined towards multitasking, not in the sense of doing two things simultaneously, but in the sense of breaking up your day to work on different things. You might spend a couple of hours on one project, then switch to another for a bit, and so on. First, let’s look at the issue of starting too many projects and how it might impact your ability to actually finish a game. A common trap is starting something new, working on it for a few weeks or months, then dropping it for a shiny new idea. I’ll admit, this has happened to me occasionally, but usually for reasons not related to the allure of a new project—sometimes life just gets in the way, and you have to reduc...
Read more

Why I’m Participating in This Year’s Spooktober Jam

Image
  Before I explain why I made this decision, let me give you some context about last year’s Spooktober Jam. Participating in this jam has become a tradition for me—this will be my fourth time taking part. However, this time around, I’ll be taking on a different role. While I’ll still lead the project, I won’t be handling the programming. Since I don’t have much experience with the Godot engine, I’ll focus on what I’m best at: production and narrative design. The idea for the narrative of this game came to me last year, right after finishing our entry for the previous Spooktober Jam. I thought, “What if we did a twisted version of the classic fairy tale Hansel and Gretel, but with a humorous twist similar to  The Addams Family ?" And that's when the idea for  Cook or Be Cooked  was born. At first, I shelved the idea because I had other projects and personal matters to focus on, but the concept kept resurfacing in my mind—how the story should unfold and how the visuals...
Read more